Wading River Pizza

6324 NY-25A, Wading River, NY 11792, USA

About Wading River Pizza

4 / 5

from reviews

    Christine Barolli
    April 19, 2024

    Food was delicious! 2 cheese pies, grandma pie and a dozen garlic knots. All perfect, knots are huge. Service was friendly and order was done in a timely manner. Online ordering wasn't working for me, called in my order and was greeted by a lovely lady who apologized and honored the online discount. My family of 5 have just decided this is our new go to pizza place!

    Dawn Vogt
    May 29, 2024

    Not good. Miss Wading River Pizza. Went in and the place was dead. The pizza was floppy, wet/mushy and super thin. No one wants a wet pizza! The flavors were subpar and there weren’t many choices. Went in on a Thursday at 4pm.

    Stacey Laudadio
    June 01, 2024

    First thing is first. When you walk in to an establishment that is empty and there are several people working..you should be greeted with a hello and a smile. Ordered 1 regular 18” pie with panko crust and 1 prosciutto arugula hot honey pie. Both pies were completely undercooked and soggy. The cheese on the regular pie is poor quality. The type of cheese that doesn’t melt nicely. Very disappointing. Fusilli’s is where it was at.

    April 22, 2024

    Being in wading river, we don’t have too many food options. As a big pizza fan, I was excited to try and Uncle Joes didn’t disappoint. The regular was really good but the Sicilian was one of the best I’ve ever had. Outstanding!!

    John W
    April 10, 2024

    This use to be Wading River Pizza. I was a long time customer and WR Pizza was great. Tonight we ordered a pie for delivery before 6PM and told it would be 30 to 45 for delivery. After the 90 minutes we called to see if there was an issue and told it was on its way. After waiting 2 hours we called to cancel the order. They would not reverse the transaction on our credit card. When my spouse told be the amount of $40 for the order I almost fell over. I have not tried their pizza but based on my experience and having been a long time customer of the previous establishment I will go elsewhere. I doubt they will be in for the long haul if this is how they start out. UPDATE: After cancelling my order DoorASS must have finally found my house. I guess they weren’t looking a tip and left my order on the front steps without knocking or ringing the bell. God only knows what time that was. So on top of the delay I got to clean up the cardboard and scraps that the raccoon left this morning on my way to work. When I see the raccoon I will get its take on the quality of the pizza and update my post 🤪

    Wading River Pizza

    Our Address

    6324 NY-25A, Wading River, NY 11792, USA

    Do You Own a Business in Suffolk County?

    If you’re a local business serving the Suffolk County community, then ShopLocalSuffolkCounty.com offers you an ideal opportunity to put your business in front of prospective customers at NO CHARGE TO YOU. What are you waiting for, it’s FREE.