They have pretty desserts on display, but when I ordered a tiramisu from them the guy who works there went to the back and gave me a smaller freezer burned cake. I asked and they don't even make their own desserts it's shipped and frozen and cost 10 dollars. The lady is also kind of rude. I only say that because it's been second time she hasn't been nice and given me weird looks. I really don't recommend their desserts; pizzas are average
J SG
-
October 26, 2024
Ugh. Not sure about their pizza but their entrees served in their dining room are horrible.Baked mozzarella sticks that were barely warm and had zero melted cheese pull. Also tasted freezer burned. Main entree of eggplant parm served warm-not hot-was tasteless except for the hint of a metallic, detergent type substance. Awful.
Morgan Kowalchuk
-
July 25, 2024
We’ve been coming here for years and our pizzas last week were horrible and incorrect. They gave us the wrong pizza so we had to go back and it still was mediocre and not worthy of New York.
We let that go and came to dine in this evening. We usually love dining in, as the food is great and the ambiance was nice with white table clothes and candles. We knew they didn’t have an abc license, so we were told we could bring our own wine in from next door or anywhere else with no corkage fee.
We came in tonight to a dirty table, with pizza boxes stacked on other booths, and no table cloths. We had to ask to have our table cleaned, and the girl wiped it off with a dry paper napkin into her hand with grease smeared. Thankfully she let us know that there would be a $30 corkage fee for wine, when they don’t even sell it.
This was all unacceptable so we unfortunately walked out. There must be a new owner and not for the best. We were upset by the two situations with pizza last week, and now we have a third. Sadly we will not return.
Kimberly Aurelio
-
July 26, 2021
Celebrated my Mother in laws 80th Birthday this weekend at Roma Liz and Willy and the entire staff were very accommodating the food was delicious and my mother in law was so happy ❤️ Thank you Liz and Willy
Eddie Hoffman
-
November 11, 2024
Pizza is too way too crispy like it was deep fried. Not horrible just not worth the price
Our Address
31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY 11935, USA
Claim Listing: Roma Pizzeria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
If you’re a local business serving the Suffolk County community, then ShopLocalSuffolkCounty.com offers you an ideal opportunity to put your business in front of prospective customers at NO CHARGE TO YOU. What are you waiting for, it’s FREE.
They have pretty desserts on display, but when I ordered a tiramisu from them the guy who works there went to the back and gave me a smaller freezer burned cake. I asked and they don't even make their own desserts it's shipped and frozen and cost 10 dollars. The lady is also kind of rude. I only say that because it's been second time she hasn't been nice and given me weird looks. I really don't recommend their desserts; pizzas are average
Ugh. Not sure about their pizza but their entrees served in their dining room are horrible.Baked mozzarella sticks that were barely warm and had zero melted cheese pull. Also tasted freezer burned. Main entree of eggplant parm served warm-not hot-was tasteless except for the hint of a metallic, detergent type substance. Awful.
We’ve been coming here for years and our pizzas last week were horrible and incorrect. They gave us the wrong pizza so we had to go back and it still was mediocre and not worthy of New York. We let that go and came to dine in this evening. We usually love dining in, as the food is great and the ambiance was nice with white table clothes and candles. We knew they didn’t have an abc license, so we were told we could bring our own wine in from next door or anywhere else with no corkage fee. We came in tonight to a dirty table, with pizza boxes stacked on other booths, and no table cloths. We had to ask to have our table cleaned, and the girl wiped it off with a dry paper napkin into her hand with grease smeared. Thankfully she let us know that there would be a $30 corkage fee for wine, when they don’t even sell it. This was all unacceptable so we unfortunately walked out. There must be a new owner and not for the best. We were upset by the two situations with pizza last week, and now we have a third. Sadly we will not return.
Celebrated my Mother in laws 80th Birthday this weekend at Roma Liz and Willy and the entire staff were very accommodating the food was delicious and my mother in law was so happy ❤️ Thank you Liz and Willy
Pizza is too way too crispy like it was deep fried. Not horrible just not worth the price