Irish Coffee Pub

131 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY 11730, USA

About Irish Coffee Pub

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    John Goleski
    May 30, 2024

    Absolutely fantastic meal. Great experience. The restaurant is run perfectly, the way they all should be. French onion soup, onion rings, potato croquet, the croutons are homemade on the salad. My lobster, clam, scallop, and jumbo shrimp dinner was so good I forced myself to bring some home so I can enjoy it again. I have been around them when they cater weddings on the east end and I wanted to try the restaurant. It was better than just 5 stars, honestly.

    Barbeque Chef
    January 26, 2024

    op Contributor I took my 94 year old Mother to a luncheon with her friends at the Irish Coffee Pub, in East Islip. I was told No Men allowed at the table!! lol So I sat at the bar and ordered a hamburger, as those 5 women just chit chatted away, in quiet!! I ordered the burger my usual medium rare, and it came to me a near perfect medium rare. The restaurant serves Certified Angus beef, so I'm assuming the burger was a chuck blend, and it had that chuck taste to it. The burger meat had a nice taste to it, to be sure. It seemed to me they hand mold the burger in house, from the structure of the burger, and the looseness of the meat as it sat in the bun. The roll they use is different from what is used at most places. It was a Kaiser roll, which I really enjoyed.. It held up very well against a very juicy burger. The French Fries were as crispy as possible, and there was certainly plenty of them, as I could not even come close to finishing all of them.. I really enjoyed them... I believe they are Hand cut One of the better French fries I have eaten. The burger was very good, but it certainly wasn't Top Tier in my Burger Hierachy. But, fact, I would not hesitate to recommend the burger if you ate there. The whole burger meat, roll, french fry combo warrants a thumbs up. The price is a bit steep,at $19.90, but it comes with fries....cheese, and any other additions were a $1 extra.. There is a charge for Credit card use The service at the Irish Coffee Pub is legendary, and it certainly shone through today. From the moment I walked in with my Mother, to the time I left, they were as gracious as could be. In fact, when I pulled the car up to the side (handicap) entrance, the manager type, Steve, noticed from inside somewhere, and came out to help with the process of getting my mother out of the car, and to get her going with her walker. The place was quite busy at lunch time. The main dining room was about half full, the various rooms around the first floor were full to different degrees, and the bar was constantly busy. There is usually plenty of parking. The weekends there are quite busy with the regular restaurant business, weddings, birthday parties, and the like.. plan accordingly. 1/25/2024

    Michael W Carmeci Sr
    April 24, 2024

    We were lucky enough to enjoy all that the Irish Coffee Pub had to offer at my Grandson's First Communion. The food and service were impeccable. This catered affair started rolls & butter, a dish of pasta, a salad, the main course, I had the Salmon which was tasty, moist and perfectly cooked, the Sliced Steak and Chicken Cordon Blue, so I was told, was also delicious and cooked to perfection. The dessert was a warm apple crumb cake ala mode. It was very tasty, and a nice end to this meal. The one drawback was the dough bottom was chewy, and not to my liking. We also brought a sheet cake to the affair. The event location was spacious with a good-sized dance floor and plenty of room around the spacious tables. The staff was attentive, friendly, and very accommodating. The management team checked in often to make sure we were satisfied. All in all, this was a great experience at this catering hall establishment. I'm unable to comment on the price since I was a guest and not the one who planned the party.

    Nance Schick
    May 15, 2024

    Have been here for events a few times and had good experiences. Service is amazing. Could use some AV equipment updates, but we make it work. Food is always good, layout is perfect, and space is beautiful. Plus, again, service is outstanding. Finally tried the dining room and was very impressed. Tried the signature Fish and Chips, which reminded me of what I’d get in London. Portions were generous, and dining room staff were as attentive and knowledgeable as the event staff. Consistently great visits. Worth the price. Highly recommend!

    Jonathan Klomp
    December 03, 2023

    December 2023 Friday night we met friends out for dinner and it was perfection. Having pride in your business, developing a brand, and doing something so exceptionally well that your customers always leave satisfied is something rare. THANK YOU. I had the surf and turf…just delicious! I’ve written about the soup before and I often dream about it because it’s always the best. One thing I never comment about with regard to service anywhere is the busing of the dishes, filling water glasses, bringing bread (delicious) when it’s empty… no place is better! A true team effort and worth every penny! Two years ago I wrote: Always exceptional…..Service is great. The vibe remains classic and the food is excellent. Pro tip I tried last night…. Ordered a mixed bowl of beef barley and potato soup… the best of both worlds!

    Irish Coffee Pub

    Our Address

    131 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY 11730, USA

    Do You Own a Business in Suffolk County?

    If you’re a local business serving the Suffolk County community, then offers you an ideal opportunity to put your business in front of prospective customers at NO CHARGE TO YOU. What are you waiting for, it’s FREE.