I’ve been going to Fratelli Pizzeria for over 20 years, and it remains my favorite go-to spot for classic pizza. The quality and flavor have been consistently excellent throughout the years. The pizza has a perfect crust, generous toppings, and a delicious sauce that never disappoints. I always make sure to order a side of their garlic knots as well—they’re the perfect complement to the pizza, with a flavorful, buttery, and garlicky finish. Fratelli Pizzeria is a cherished favorite, and I highly recommend it for anyone craving a reliably great pizza experience.
Taralynn Doring
-
June 06, 2024
I have been a customer for the past 4 years. Everything on the menu is freshly made. Their pizza beats any pizza you will find here all the way to the end of Manhattan and I've tried it all. They strive for perfection. My own mom who is a picky Italian fell in love with their eggplant Parmesan with spaghetti on the side which features their own sauce on top. Rice balls are to die for. I never have a problem with the bill because I know I'm being served with fresh quality food straight from Italian recipes.
Jim Casey
-
October 19, 2023
First time here and wow it was good pizza! John the owner so friendly and welcoming. Definitely will be back to try his dinners.
Michelle Alese
-
August 10, 2024
This place is an absolute gem - the Italian food is very high quality and everything I’ve tried from there is delicious. The people who work there are also very friendly and welcoming. 10/10 recommend!
Sharon Hendricks
-
July 30, 2022
First time eating food from this establishment and I ordered through Uber Eats. I was a little hesitant because of my last two experiences ordering from two different pizzerias in Bay Shore whereas I ordered calzones and pizza. They weren' very good experiences and I didn't want a three-peat. I ordered two calzones, one with pepperoni and one with meatballs. Unfortunately, I didn't get meatballs in one f the calzones and I got Italian sausages which I specifically didn't want and a large neopolitan.
Despite the error of giving me Italian sausage the calzone was really good. The calzone was packed with an even amount of ricotta and mozzarella and just the right amount of sausage. I emphasis that as I had just ordered from another pizzeria a few weeks ago and the calzone was disgusting, in look and in taste. This pizza was made well and it also had ample and equal amounts of sauce and cheese. It was flavorful. The pizza dough was baked just right and the pizza wasn't greasy or soggy. I think the prices are competitive and actually worth it. Some places have charged $ 10 more for the same size pie. I would certainly order from here again and recommend it as a really good pizzeria.
Our Address
553 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA
Claim Listing: Fratelli Pizzeria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
If you’re a local business serving the Suffolk County community, then ShopLocalSuffolkCounty.com offers you an ideal opportunity to put your business in front of prospective customers at NO CHARGE TO YOU. What are you waiting for, it’s FREE.
I’ve been going to Fratelli Pizzeria for over 20 years, and it remains my favorite go-to spot for classic pizza. The quality and flavor have been consistently excellent throughout the years. The pizza has a perfect crust, generous toppings, and a delicious sauce that never disappoints. I always make sure to order a side of their garlic knots as well—they’re the perfect complement to the pizza, with a flavorful, buttery, and garlicky finish. Fratelli Pizzeria is a cherished favorite, and I highly recommend it for anyone craving a reliably great pizza experience.
I have been a customer for the past 4 years. Everything on the menu is freshly made. Their pizza beats any pizza you will find here all the way to the end of Manhattan and I've tried it all. They strive for perfection. My own mom who is a picky Italian fell in love with their eggplant Parmesan with spaghetti on the side which features their own sauce on top. Rice balls are to die for. I never have a problem with the bill because I know I'm being served with fresh quality food straight from Italian recipes.
First time here and wow it was good pizza! John the owner so friendly and welcoming. Definitely will be back to try his dinners.
This place is an absolute gem - the Italian food is very high quality and everything I’ve tried from there is delicious. The people who work there are also very friendly and welcoming. 10/10 recommend!
First time eating food from this establishment and I ordered through Uber Eats. I was a little hesitant because of my last two experiences ordering from two different pizzerias in Bay Shore whereas I ordered calzones and pizza. They weren' very good experiences and I didn't want a three-peat. I ordered two calzones, one with pepperoni and one with meatballs. Unfortunately, I didn't get meatballs in one f the calzones and I got Italian sausages which I specifically didn't want and a large neopolitan. Despite the error of giving me Italian sausage the calzone was really good. The calzone was packed with an even amount of ricotta and mozzarella and just the right amount of sausage. I emphasis that as I had just ordered from another pizzeria a few weeks ago and the calzone was disgusting, in look and in taste. This pizza was made well and it also had ample and equal amounts of sauce and cheese. It was flavorful. The pizza dough was baked just right and the pizza wasn't greasy or soggy. I think the prices are competitive and actually worth it. Some places have charged $ 10 more for the same size pie. I would certainly order from here again and recommend it as a really good pizzeria.